• Why I switched from Xfce to Gnome 3


    From Cinnamon to Mate to Enlightenment and finally Xfce. Why I switched to Gnome 3.

    I like multiple desktops. I used to keep 4, then I expanded to 6. I liked compiz and the fancy rotating cube. If you are a Linux power user you know what I’m talking about.

    People have moved away from Gnome (pronounced “Ga-Nome” not “Nome”) when Gnome went from version 2 to version 3. That’s when Mate and Cinnamon were born, even Ubuntu’s Unity shell.

    I’ve come back to Gnome.

    My Gnome DesktopAs you can see from the image, my desktop looks very similar to any other desktop environment. I even have a rotating wallpaper image.

    What I like, and I’m getting use to it and finding it very productive, is the “expand as you go” desktop model. You start with one. If your computer screen gets too cluttered, press ctrl-alt-down-arrow and you go to the next one. (Note in Gnome we go up and down instead of side to side with most other desktop enviornments).

    The desktops are dynamically allocated. That’s cool. Then I just watched some YouTube videos (there’s tons) how to customize your Gnome desktop, and you wind up with what you see above. Icons on the desktop, a taskbar (with a shadow!) along the top, some icons I can click on the bottom, and the whole desktop wallpaper changes once a minute (or once every however long you want it to be) with a little tweaking.

    I have it all set up now. I spent two days on it. I will probably spend more days on it in the future, but all day I’ve been inside Gnome, using it, whizzing around, no loss of productivity what-so-ever. In fact, I hardly notice most of the time what desktop environment I’m in. Gnome stays out of my way except when I need it.

    You’ll read some negative reviews of Gnome 3. As stated, a lot of people migrated away from it when Gnome 3 moved further away from Gnome 2. I was one of those people. I stayed away for years.

    Now I’m back. I like what I see. I’m going to stay with it.

    Don’t be proud! Watch some cool YouTube videos about how to set up Gnome Shell to give you all kinds of wizard tricks, bells and whistles.

  • @shwaybotx
    Just wait untill the next Gnome/GTK3 update breaks everything.
    J.

  • @shwaybotx good review :+1: i did give Gnome “i just say NOME ;)” a really good look. had it for several months. i had a problem kinda like what @Jeannie____ was talking about. the extensions give me the desktop that works for me but unfortunately when there is a gnome update and the dev doesn’t update the extension it can sometime break. i rely so much on these extensions to work to give me that desktop i want. i cant work with the tablet interface.

    i wish Gnome would give the users that desktop choice that is officially supported and not by only extensions. that fallback mode to classic gnome is pointless. if you are going to use that you might as well use Mate.

    thats great it works for you i have a feeling though a lot of traditional desktop users are going to stay away. so many great desktop choices out like KDE, Mate and openbox :)

  • @megaman said in Why I switched from Xfce to Gnome 3:

    i wish Gnome would give the users that desktop choice that is officially supported and not by only extensions. that fallback mode to classic gnome is pointless. if you are going to use that you might as well use Mate.

    thats great it works for you i have a feeling though a lot of traditional desktop users are going to stay away. so many great desktop choices out like KDE, Mate and openbox :)

    I agree, if i want to make a Gnome look like Mate then i just use Mate hehehe. Both Gnome and KDE are slow to me, so i rather use i3-wm (now) and Mate (before). I like cleaner and simpler apps/programs etc.
    The extension’s dependency is terrible too, you can’t add a menu at the pannel or set it to bottom screen unless you use extensions.
    BUT linux has options for everyone :)

    Antergos (default OS) - WIN10 (abandoned)
    I3wm - Mate desktop
    AMD - A4 7300 Radeon graphics
    16 GB ram
    HD 1 TB
    Linux newbie since 06/2016

switched1 xfce47 gnome210 Posts 4Views 503
Log in to reply